
ER&D Submission Guideline
Submission Types
We are accepting empirical studies, literature reviews, position papers, and book reviews relevant to issues of learning, teaching, and schooling at different levels and from various fields. We would like to take this opportunity to encourage all professional educators and researchers to contribute. Below you will find specific requirements for each submission type.
(1) Empirical Study
Each manuscript should not exceed 8,000 words, excluding the cover page, abstract and keywords, references, tables, and figures. Each submitted empirical study should include the following sections, although they can be titled and structured in different ways or order that will help facilitate readers’ understanding of the study:
- Introduction section that articulates the study's focus and questions, explains the concepts, ideas, and assumptions leading to the study's focus and questions, and justifies the importance of the focus and questions from scholarship, policy, and/or practice perspectives,
- Theoretical framework section that introduces the backgrounds of each theoretical framework, articulates the concepts, ideas, and assumptions of each theoretical framework, and explains how each theoretical frame will be used in the study,
- Empirical literature review section that carefully situates the study in the current empirical understanding of its focus and questions, identifies the contributions and limitations of the current literature in developing empirical understandings of the question of this study, and how the study will help address the limitation of the current literature,
- Methodology section that specifically explains and justifies the research design, participants and samples, contexts, data sources, and analysis that will help answer your research questions reliably and with validity,
- Findings or results section that develops answers to each research question of the study, supports each answer using valid evidence generated from data analysis, and interprets the conflicting results emerging from the analysis.
- Discussion section that interprets the study results, explains the empirical and/or theoretical contributions of these results to the existing literature, and identifies the relevant future directions of research, and
- Conclusion and implications section that synthesizes the study's conclusions and discusses the specific implications of these conclusions for policymakers and/or practitioners in the field.
(2) Literature Review
Each literature review manuscript should not exceed 8,000 words, excluding the cover page, abstract and keywords, references, tables, and figures. Each submitted literature review should include the following sections, although they can be titled and structured in different ways or order that will help facilitate readers' understanding of the study:
- Introduction section that articulates the importance of the review's focus and questions from the perspectives of scholarship, policy, and/or practice and justifies the uniqueness and necessity of the literature review by comparing it to other relevant reviews and/or discusses its potential contribution to the relevant field,
- Conceptualization section that articulates the conception(s) or theoretical perspective(s) framing the literature review's assumptions, organization, and analysis,
- Results section that reports the focuses, participants and/or sample, interventions, if any, data sources, and results from the studies reviewed based on the relevant review questions, interprets similar, different, and/or mixed results from the reviewed studies, and identifies the strengths and weaknesses of their research methods,
- Synthesis section that discusses the contribution of the results to the understanding of its relevant questions, analyzes the limitations of the results, and identifies relevant future work in the field, and
- Conclusions and Implications section that develops the overall conclusions relevant to its questions based on the results from the literature review and offers specific implications for the relevant communities of scholarship, policy making, and/or practice accordingly.
(3) Position Paper
Each manuscript should not exceed 8,000 words, excluding the cover page, abstract and keywords, references, tables, and figures. Each submitted position paper should include the following sections, although they can be titled and structured in different ways or order that will help facilitate readers’ understanding of the study:
- Introduction section that defines the issue(s) for the paper, justifies the issue(s) using appropriate literature and data as support, and articulates the importance of the issue(s) to a particular field,
- Analysis section that conceptualizes the issue(s), analyzes the development of the issue(s) in the relevant historical, economic, social, cultural, and/or political contexts, clarifies the emerging scholarship understanding relevant to the issue(s), and identifies the needs of relevant research, policy development, and/or practice in addressing the issues,
- Discussion section that provides insights on how to address the issue(s) and discusses the specific implications of its resolution for the relevant scholarship, policy development, and practice, and
- Conclusion and Implications section that develops the conclusions based on the analysis and discussion of the issue(s), identifies remaining questions, and offers direction(s) for future work.
(4) Book Review
Each manuscript should not exceed 2,000 words, excluding the cover page, abstract and keywords, references, tables, and figures. Each submitted book review should include the following sections, although they can be titled and structured in different ways or order that will help facilitate readers’ understanding of the study:
- Introduction section that provides a summary of the book, including its authors, publication information (i.e., outlet and date), and describes the book's focus and scope,
- Review section that explains the book's arguments within the context of past and current research, describes how these arguments are developed and substantiated, and discusses the strengths and weaknesses of the rhetoric used in the book in developing its arguments,
- Methodology section that examines the methodology, literature, and other data sources used in the book and identifies the strengths and weaknesses of these literature, methods, and data sources in developing and sustaining these arguments,
- Conclusion and implication section that offers a scholarly opinion or comments on the book and discusses its benefits and drawbacks in the relevant field,
- Audience section that identifies the book's usefulness for a specific audience based on the results of the review.
Submission Requirements
All manuscripts should be original and neither submitted nor published elsewhere. They should be written following APA guidelines of the American Psychological Association Publication Manual, 7th edition, and saved as a Microsoft word document.
Each submission should also include the following files submitted separately:
- A cover page (one file) in which authors include: 1) the title of the manuscript, 2) authors’ name and title, institutional affiliation, business, and home phone numbers, and e-mail addresses, and 3) the date of submission
- An abstract (one file) in which authors describe the essence of the manuscript in no more than 150 words without references and an indication of the author's identity. Three keywords should also be provided to help define the focus of the manuscript
- A blinded manuscript (one file) that includes title, abstract, manuscript text, references, tables, figures, etc.
Blinded ManuscriptAs submitted manuscripts will be reviewed on a double-blind basis, please be sure to remove anything in the manuscript that will help reveal the authors' identity. In places where authors cite their own work (including those they co-authored with other scholars), the manuscript text and reference list at the end, should write "author(s)" followed by the publication date. All these references should be placed under the letter A. Please do not include titles or coauthors' names in such citations and references. Any manuscript that does not follow the above requirements will be returned to the author(s) for correction and resubmission. This may delay the review process for the manuscript.
Important Note: Manuscripts submitted or published elsewhere, over the word limit, not following APA guidelines, not saved as Word documents, and/or submissions that do not include all of the required files and information will be returned to the authors without going through any review process. Thus, it is important that authors check their manuscripts and relevant files carefully and be sure that they all meet the relevant requirements before submission.
Submission Deadlines and Review Process (Tentative)The
Educational Research and Development Journal receives all manuscript submissions electronically via the journal’s online submission website located at:
https://www.viethconsulting.com/members/proposals/propselect.php?orgcode=CAER.
To be fully considered for review and publication, all manuscripts must be submitted to the journal submission website. Authors will be notified with a receipt of submission after successful submission.
Below is the estimated timeline of the review process:
After an initial review by the editors, authors with manuscripts meeting all the requirements will be informed whether their manuscripts will be forwarded to the reviewers for further blinded review in two weeks
. The authors of those manuscripts sent for blind review will be informed of the review results and editorial decisions for their manuscripts in one month. Authors who receive requested revisions need to complete and submit their revised manuscript to the journal following instructions provided in a decision letter in one month
. The journal editors reserve the right to make editorial changes to each manuscript to be accepted for publication.
Inquiries can be sent by e-mail to:
jian.wang@ttu.edu and/or
raymond.flores@ttu.edu.